MoreRSS

site iconChuck JordanModify

A writer, programmer, and game designer living in Los Angeles, California.
Please copy the RSS to your reader, or quickly subscribe to:

Inoreader Feedly Follow Feedbin Local Reader

Rss preview of Blog of Chuck Jordan

One Thing I Love About Victorian Psycho

2026-11-15 14:34:50

I really enjoyed the book Victorian Psycho, so my heart sank when I found out that a movie adaptation was already in the works. So much of what makes the book special is the specificity of Winnifred Notty’s viewpoint. She’s not purely chaotic, and she’s not calculating and manipulative, either. It could have been nothing more than lurid horror or broad satire without the understated and matter-of-fact way she observed and described everything.

But there were two points in the movie’s favor: one is that it was being adapted by Virginia Feito, the book’s author. The other was that Maika Monroe had been cast as Winnifred Notty.

I’ve only seen two of Monroe’s movies, It Follows and Longlegs, but just those were enough to turn me into a big fan. Not only does she embrace genre movies, she has the presence to command your attention without making choices that are too showy, and aren’t true to the character. Both of those movies require her to play variations on “numb,” and she plays the part with a kind of thoughtful stillness that is, somehow, captivating.

And I think she’s great in Victorian Psycho, to the point that it’s tough for me to imagine any other actor who’d have been able to pull it off.1 She spends much of the movie with a kind of wide-eyed, almost drunk expression, as if she’s taking everything in and letting it all wash over her. Occasionally, she takes on the mannerisms of Data from Star Trek, reminding us that every bit of behavior that seems “normal” has been carefully observed and practiced in private.

That means that she’s inscrutable for much of the movie, especially in the beginning. Without being able to listen to her thoughts, you’d think that she was alternating between periods of clarity and psychotic episodes, instead of operating at a constant level of observation and compulsion, while putting on an act of Victorian propriety when it’s necessary. Which means that voice-overs are pretty much a necessity, which means that I’m very glad Feito adapted her own book.

I normally hate voice-overs. Even when they’re done out of affection for the source material (like in The Life of Chuck), they always seem like a crutch and a cop-out. In this adaptation, I was pleasantly surprised that Feito wasn’t at all precious about her own work, getting the chance to see her favorite passages committed to screen. Instead, she carefully chooses the voice-overs based on how they function, and the essential pieces of information that get across. And they’re mostly limited to information that can’t really be conveyed any other way. After the characters have been established, they’re a lot more sparing, and she chooses a more cinematic moment to get across the idea.

One key example is when Miss Notty is introduced to the children of the Pounds family for their first lesson, which is, appropriately, about knowing the difference between right and wrong. After she asks a question and is met with only silence from the children, we hear her in voice-over matter-of-factly declare that she suspects the children are both idiots.

It’s crucial because Miss Notty adamantly doesn’t believe that any of these people are her superiors. My favorite description in the book is when she meets the family and describes them as “disappointing.” At the same time, she’s not really an anti-hero, and she doesn’t believe that everything she does is right. She acknowledges that there’s an evil inside her, and she has a line later on (in voice over) where she says that she doesn’t know if she swallowed the darkness, or it swallowed her. But she treats it as a part of who she is, along the same lines as her gender or her social class.

That idea is reinforced with dialogue in the same scene, where the daughter Drusilla, the only member of the Pounds family with any sense of the injustices and evils of Victorian society, asks whether Miss Notty thinks it’s unfair that people of “lower classes” are fated to live such miserable lives. Notty answers that it isn’t unfair; it’s just the way things are.

So I was more or less content to treat the voice-overs as a necessary evil, handled about as well as they could be. But the scene where we first see Miss Notty murder someone took the voice-overs and made them cinematic. After a sinister and beautifully-shot setup, we see the flashes of violence punctuated by solid blackness, only hearing Notty’s matter-of-fact observations about what’s happening. It’s really effective, selling the idea that she frequently loses time and acts purely on impulse, even when she’s doing something that was clearly premeditated. And that her mind has a kind of clarity and impartiality, making her an observer of her own bizarre actions as much as everyone else’s.

Feito and Monroe don’t deserve all the credit for making Victorian Psycho work, of course. There’s a lot of great and varied imagery throughout, cutting abruptly between moments of period drama and moments of insanity. I was especially impressed that it’s not simply the same visual tics repeated over and over again. You can never predict how the next psychotic break is going to be visualized, and it’s always jarring and interesting. One of my favorites used lenses2 to put Notty in the center of the frame as she’s traveling through the house, will all the perfectly straight lines of the wainscoting being twisted into curves and spirals.

One of the best and strangest scenes in the book has Notty giving in to one of her compulsions concerning the naive Miss Lamb, and I thought the movie did a fantastic job of depicting a moment that I’d have thought would be completely inscrutable without voice-over. It’s perfectly shot and edited, being both surreal and tense and disorienting, and culminating in a bizarre and suspenseful peek-a-boo with a crying baby. And only at the end of the scene, a perfectly-chosen matter-of-fact voice-over.

And while Maika Monroe understandably has to do most of the heavy lifting, all of the performances are excellent. Everybody involved seems to understand exactly what movie they’re making, which is especially remarkable when the performances have to range from naturalistic to broad3. Jason Isaacs is particularly good as Mr Pounds, actually improving on the character from the book. He doesn’t feature quite as prominently as in the book, but he makes the most of every moment. From casually and matter-of-factly describing his father abusing him as a child, to a queasy scene of sexual assault in which he actually delivers a pitch-black funny line.4

That scene is another example of how this is a confident adaptation. I’d been concerned that the movie was being too sympathetic to Mr Pounds, and it had cut out his whole lecherous subplot. But it’s all consolidated into one scene, and it works well.

I still think I prefer the book to the movie, but Victorian Psycho is a pretty great example of how to adapt an extremely “interior” book into a visual medium, keeping all of its most important ideas intact. It’s far less violent than I’d expected, especially in the way it depicts the climactic night. I’d expected that to be the key set piece of a movie version, so I was pleasantly surprised by the movie’s restraint.

Another great image is when Notty is climbing a staircase in the house during one of her episodes, and she looks up to see that the ceiling has been replaced with a swirling view of the entire galaxy. It’s surreal and disorienting, but it’s also a powerful image to underscore one of the story’s key themes: we’ve all been dropped into this existence with no understanding of how it works and why we’re here, and all we can do is make sense of it the best we can.

While again, Victorian Psycho doesn’t make Miss Notty the hero, it does seem to believe her claim that “I’m the sanest person I know.” It doesn’t suggest that she was a product of her upbringing, but that her psychosis makes her one of the few people who can see Victorian society for what it is. Built on racism, cruelty, misogyny, classism, all passing itself off as politeness, civility, and Christian righteousness.

1    Jessie Buckley comes to mind, but everything I’ve seen her in gives me the sense of a very good actor. Monroe always seems to be the character she’s playing.
2    I’m assuming; it might have been more of the movie’s very sparing but effective use of visual effects. Another highlight was when she was looking into a fireplace and saw demonic-looking runes just barely perceptible in the sparks.
3    Like for instance, the horrible high-society dinner guests.
4    It’s when she calls him “father” and he says, “You don’t need to say that.”

Fresh Meat, or, Feed Good People

2026-11-01 15:04:05

Earlier this year, the people behind the Dead Meat channel announced a project called Fresh Meat, an anthology of short horror films from up-and-coming filmmakers. The collection would get a theatrical and home streaming release, exposure from being promoted on the channel, and a cut of the revenue.

I’ve been one of the channel’s many fans for a couple of years now, and I think this is a fantastic project. The creators of Dead Meat, James A Janisse and Chelsea Rebecca, are former film students who decided to ditch the pretentiousness I associate with film students (I’m allowed to say that since I was one briefly) and go all-in on embracing a genre that they love, without much caring whether it’s considered “low-brow.” Their earnest enthusiasm for the process of making movies comes through in their videos and podcasts, and they’ve got a bullshit-free positivity that carries through everything. You can tell that this is a heartfelt project designed to use their platform to give new filmmakers a boost.

I’d reserved a ticket to see it at my local AMC theater for its one night of theatrical screenings, but couldn’t make it. So I was happy to see it come to Apple TV, so I could buy a copy to throw at least a little bit of money at the project.

Even with that enthusiasm, though, I didn’t have the highest of expectations. Anthologies are inherently hit-or-miss, and adding the horror genre and an open call for unknown filmmakers into the mix seems like it’d be practically asking for stuff that was unwatchable with only a few solid attempts. They put up a list of finalists with a trailer for each of their movies and gave the internet a chance to vote for their favorites, and there were only a couple that immediately grabbed me.

So I was pleasantly surprised by how much I liked it. They’re not all 100% to my taste, but that’s to be expected of any anthology. In fact, it’s a testament to the curation that went into this one, that there’s such a wide variety of styles and tones. There’s an animated one, a few primarily comedic ones, one that feels like an acting exercise turned into horror, a couple that are new takes on familiar urban legends, and only a couple that feel like the pretentious film student projects I’d expected.

Most surprising is that there’s not really a dud in the bunch. Even my least favorites had some appealing aspect to them, and I’ve seen several reviews on Letterboxd that called those out as their favorites. There seems to be something for all types of horror fans, and the entries are all short enough (I believe they’re all under 10 minutes?) that if you’re not vibing with one, it doesn’t overstay its welcome.

As somebody who’s only started really getting into horror over the past five or six years, I’ve been a little surprised and happy to see the kind of community that’s grown up around it. The vibe seems to have gotten more mature and more inclusive since I first became aware of horror fandom as a thing; it seems to be less about being an edgelord now, and more about being a nice person who can still nerd out over inventively visceral filmmaking.

I think projects like this would deserve support anyway, and it’s just a nice bonus that it’s actually pretty entertaining!

Deadly Friend, or, Number Five Is Undead

2026-11-01 06:04:47

A recurring, and inadvertent, theme has started to develop from the movies I’ve enjoyed the most this year, and that is: “I wouldn’t have been able to appreciate this if I’d seen it on release.” I’ve seen a lot of stuff that forces me to imagine myself in the 80s or early 90s, with my still-developing understanding of movies, and art in general for that matter, and wondering whether that version of me would have been able to understand how it works.

I’m certain, however, that I would not have been able to understand Deadly Friend as a teenager. Because I’m not sure I understand it as an adult.

The movie stars Matthew Labyorteaux as a teen (?) genius who’s an expert in robotics and AI, and who’s built a robot friend named BB. He and his mom have moved to a suburban house in a new town, because he’s gotten a full scholarship to a university to study (and occasionally, teach) brain surgery, a subject he’s also an expert in, somehow. He’s made discoveries that even his sponsors were incapable of.

His new next-door neighbor is Sam, played by Kristy Swanson, a friendly teenager living alone with her abusive, alcoholic father. Paul, Sam, BB, and their other friend Tom the newspaper delivery boy love to hang out and do teen stuff together, like shooting hoops, doing pranks on Halloween, and antagonizing the paranoid old woman across the street. But when Sam is killed in what her abusive father claims is an accident, Paul hatches a plan to save her by implanting BB’s electronic brain into her body.

Going in, I knew three things about this movie: the premise, that it’s by horror master Wes Craven, and there’s a scene involving a basketball that is a highlight. All of those things are true. And yet, the movie that exists is so different from the one that I’d been imagining that it feels like something that couldn’t exist even now, much less in 1986. A bafflingly unique new genre that consists solely of itself.

Incidentally: if you haven’t seen it, do not look through the images on imdb or online, since people just straight-up spoil all of the best moments.

What makes it so unique is that it is, undeniably, a horror comedy, but I can’t think of any other movie I’ve seen that commits so thoroughly to the bit. It plays like an opportunistic take on the Amblin Entertainment-style teen adventures that were so common in the 1980s, with every scene, every camera angle, every bit of background music, every performance, and every light-hearted gag a pitch-perfect approximation of that. But they all feel as if they’ve been filtered through the mind of a mad genius.

I have to wonder whether my “this is like nothing I’ve ever seen before” reaction is due to my age, my general inability to understand kayfabe like the younger generations do, my still-incomplete experience with horror movies, or a combination of the three. Does this read as nothing more than obvious comedy horror to people who didn’t grow up in the same popular entertainment environment as I did, and who may not appreciate that all the cheesy and corny stuff in Deadly Friend was just the way movies were back in the 1980s?

BB the robot1 is voiced — a lot — by Charles Fleischer, doing the kinds of “cute” gurgles and muttering that he and Frank Welker built entire careers out of. BB’s artificial intelligence is so advanced that he doesn’t need to be programmed; he can just teach himself things like picking locks and grabbing the genitals of bullies. There is the requisite scene of our hero and his friends getting accosted by a gang of motorcycle-riding bad seeds, and you can tell that the head bully is bad news because he wears a dangling earring, and it’s one of the fundamentals of 80s Teen Movies when we see the bully get his comeuppance at the claws of a cute and plucky robot. The movie is full of scenes that play out like lighthearted “comedy” familiar to anyone who’d seen literally any piece of media made between 1980 and 1990.

But while the familiar Teen Whiz Kid story is playing out, we get gruesome close-ups of brain surgery like it’s a horror movie, and the dark story of Sam’s abuse that’s presented like a Very Special Episode of a sitcom or made-for-TV movie. While Paul and his friend Tom are rushing to the hospital to execute their dark plan to reanimate their dead friend, Tom is freaking out over Paul’s driving, and Paul dutifully hits every single trash can. Breakfast with Paul’s mom has the teens up to their wacky hijinx of figuring out how to slip a sedative into her coffee, and whew! her reaction on tasting it is just to say “I make a good cup of coffee!” Later, there’s a hilarious moment of misunderstanding when our teen hero thinks he’s accidentally used too strong a dose and killed his mother! Oh, Paul!

It did such a good job of transporting me back to the early 80s that I was almost immediately back in the mindset of my adolescent crush on Labyorteaux (and his brother Patrick), which was somehow more confusing and inexplicable to me than my crushes on Buck Rogers and Starbuck, because Little House on the Prairie wasn’t set in space. Shouldn’t I have been crushing on Kristy Swanson instead? Watching it now, it was odd seeing Labyorteaux, who was clearly an adult (he was 20 when this was released), playing a character that I assumed must be a teenager around 15. The movie seemed to be putting him in long-sleeve shirts to hide how hairy his arms were for an adolescent, until it eventually just gives up and shows him in his underwear.

To quote MST3K: “Really old teenagers from outer space!”

My own psychosexual confusion aside, Deadly Friend is confounding because it always feels like a jarring mismatch of tones, light and dark clumsily and shamelessly slammed together, but at the same time, it always feels exactly tonally appropriate for a movie from whatever bizarre alternate reality it comes from. In lesser hands, this could have turned into something like Zapped! or Weird Science, but with the comedy replaced with horror. Instead, it feels like someone making a completely straight-faced version of this story in the style of a light-hearted teen adventure, totally unaware of how dark and weird it is. And without even the slightest bit of concern over whether anyone in the audience knows that the filmmakers are in on the joke.

Or in fact, whether it’s even supposed to be a joke. The only hint of awareness I could pick up on was after Paul tells Tom about his plan, the camera cuts to the outside of the house and we hear Tom in voiceover yell “Are you out of your fucking mind?!” (And also, I guess, the basketball scene).

So when zombie Sam (you can tell she’s a zombie on account of all the eye makeup) and her new robot brain (you can tell she’s got a robot brain because she always holds her hands like BB’s pincers) go on a revenge murder spree, it doesn’t feel to me like comedy horror, because it doesn’t feel at all self aware. It just seems like this is what a perfectly normal movie would be like in some alternate bizarro-reality.

It’s a reality where of course a computer chip is enough to give a teen girl super-human strength, and where an overt parody of 80s movies like, say, Wet Hot American Summer seems even more desperate than it does in our reality to make certain the audience knows this is supposed to be funny.

Even the slyness of something like M3GAN feels more clumsy and overt. Deadly Friend has no trace of that movie’s satirical intent — I don’t think there’s any point behind it other than to be bafflingly awesome — but it does feel way ahead of its time in comparison. Neither BB nor Sam ever breaks into a heartfelt song, but you’ll also never catch anyone involved in this movie winking at the camera.

I’m only barely exaggerating when I say that Deadly Friend should be required viewing for anyone interested in cinema studies, if not quite making it an essential piece of the western canon of film history. Especially if you grew up during a period where the style of movie and TV storytelling this movie approximates is the only thing you ever had access to. I genuinely believe it’s the best Wes Craven movie I’ve seen, re-contextualizing the way that genre movies work in a way that makes Scream feel blunt and old-fashioned.

1    And occasionally, bizarrely, the zombie teen girl

Remnants, or, Are The Spirits In The Room With Us?

2026-11-01 04:28:11

When Apple’s Vision Pro headset was having its moment in the public consciousness, there was a ton of pushback that was way overblown and hyperbolic. Apart from its exorbitant price (which is undeniable), there were comments that made it sound like wearing it was like wearing some medieval torture device, and that it was a symbol of a bleak dystopian future where we’re all shut-ins, jacked into the dark solitude of cyberspace, completely cut off from our loved ones, pets, and the wonders of nature.

In practice as an early adopter, the only thing I’ve found isolating about it is that when I do see something genuinely cool on it, I know that there’s going to be a limited audience who’s even capable of seeing it. Mostly because of that exorbitant price.

A perfect example of that is Remnants, a 30-minute horror movie written and directed by Ti West for the Apple Immersive platform.

So far, I haven’t been blown away by any of the Apple Immersive projects, because while they’re all well-done, the ones I’ve seen have felt mostly like novelties. You do get the queasy feeling of vertigo from watching a woman walk a tight rope across an impossibly deep chasm. It is neat seeing the streets and rooftops of Paris as a bunch of parkour experts leap across the architecture. And I imagine it’d be neat to be close enough to Metallica to see every pore, bead of sweat, and hair on the faces of the artists, but I’m not into Metallica enough to want to find out. There’s one fiction project that I know of, about people in a submarine, and I’m sure that the format will get across the tension and claustrophobia in a way that traditional movies can’t, but I’ve never been particularly compelled to check it out.

But a ghost story: that I can get into. Remnants is set in England sometime during the Edwardian period, I’m guessing, and it stars Lucy Boynton as the representative of a bank assigned to assess the remnants of the estate of a recently-deceased noble woman. She’s there on behalf of her husband, who’s suffering from some sort of consumptive disease that causes him to have sudden episodes of extreme close-up jump scares. At the start, she’s trying to convince the estate’s caretaker, played by Ralph Ineson, to guide her through the old mansion. When he refuses, she decides she’ll just go by herself.

What’s so remarkable about Remnants is that it simply wouldn’t be as effective in any other medium. I don’t think it’s spoiling anything to say that the story is very straightforward and old-school, and it’s filled with every haunted house movie trick in the book. But it’s a simple story executed to the absolute fullest extent. The production design is flawless, the performances are perfect, the visual effects are (mostly) seamless, and every single shot works to establish atmosphere and tension.

It starts with Boynton and Ineson’s characters at a table in a dark pub in front of a fireplace, and it’s both the perfect introduction to an old-fashioned ghost story, and an ingenious way to ease the viewer into an immersive-format short film.1 You’re placed into the room as a silent observer, aware of the other patrons in your periphery, instinctively wanting to look around and explore your space, but also your attention is drawn to the speakers. There’s a vague sense that those other patrons aren’t just background extras; you’re one of them. Like in a traditional movie, a private conversation has been presented exclusively to you as an omnipresent observer; but at the same time, you’ve been cast as someone in a pub who’s eavesdropping on a heated conversation at a nearby table.

I don’t want to get too hyperbolic with it, but I did keep getting that energizing feeling of what it must have felt like as cinema first departed from recording stage productions, and started experimenting with what the camera could do that made it unique to the new medium. Partly because I was immediately engaged in the story — this doesn’t feel like a novelty or a tech demo — I got the feeling of a team breaking cinematic storytelling down to first principles. It’s not like traditional movies, since you’re there in the room, but it’s also not like immersive theater, since the filmmakers can command your focus and put you in any position they want. Even, or especially in this case, places you would not have chosen to go on your own.

As somebody who’s spent decades engaging with video game storytelling, and years seeing how much of that does or doesn’t translate naturally to VR, I noticed how many of the “fundamental rules” are broken in Remnants. The camera abruptly cuts between setups. Some of the camera positions are slightly tilted, enough to be disorienting without being nauseating. And the camera will often do a slow pan or a push through a space, which I’ve always assumed would be forbidden, to avoid motion sickness. I was surprised by how well it all works.

The movie isn’t made with 360-degree cameras, but instead an angle more like 180 degrees. If you look behind you, you’ll just see the scene dissolve into blackness. But there’s always something just outside your range of peripheral vision. Meaning that you naturally watch what the camera is currently focused on, but you’re also constantly looking around for anything that might be lurking in the shadows. Which is, of course, perfect for a story about a haunted house. It’s not a story told in the first person, but instead often feels like you might be one of the ghosts.

And I’ve got to praise how the movie’s paced, which is a huge but subtle part of how that effect works. Shots go on for much longer than they would in a traditional movie, often with several seconds passing before our protagonist enters the frame. It’s essential to let us get our bearings, but also imbues a sense of anticipation throughout the movie, as we’re always wondering exactly why the camera is holding on this shot, scanning the periphery to find out exactly what it might be showing us. I can’t imagine this would feel anything other than dull and padded in a traditional movie, even a 3D one.

But Remants is thoroughly, and unapologetically, a horror movie, meaning that the building sense of dread comes from anticipating the moments that you’ll see something horrific in your periphery, which will inevitably jump out and getcha. The movie is absolutely not above throwing in old-school 3D jump scares. But they are all hell of effective.

It’s not even like the VR horror games I’ve tried2, largely because you’re ceding any sense of control. You’re not the protagonist, you have no agency in this story apart from watching what happens, but you’re not an impartial viewer, either. You’re right there in the room. And the camera can cut at any moment to show you exactly what the protagonist is seeing. There are plenty of times I’ve had an effective jump scare in a traditional movie. None of them have ever given me the full-body electric tingling jolt that the ones in Remants do.

Those moments are closer to a haunted house attraction than a movie or video game, but even when I’ve been in those and had an actual person inches away from my real-world face trying to scare the shit out of me, it’s never been the same level of biological flight-response terror. Again, it felt like taking things back to the fundamentals of cinema, and enjoying the simple fact that the camera can be anywhere and do anything.

Which all goes back to my opening paragraph. It’s impossible for me to watch this and not be excited about the potential of an entirely new medium. Not the future of entertainment, obviously, but a future, instead of just being the novelty branch I’d kind of dismissed it as being. This is the first thing I’ve seen in a long time that felt like an entirely new art form — not just from its content, but from its execution. All the money and talent and imagination went into this project, and it shows.

And it’s a drag to realize that its audience is inherently limited, because the tech (and budget) that makes it possible is still out of reach for most people.

1    As an indication of how immersive the movie is, I’d originally typed “ease the player” without noticing.
2    With the caveat that I haven’t tried many, and never for very long, because they freak me out

Black Sabbath, or, Snore Pigs

2026-10-31 01:00:00

The poster for the American release of Black Sabbath shows a headless man barreling through the countryside carrying the decapitated head of one of his victims, while four young women bare their ample cleavage in horror. You can’t quite call it false advertising, but it definitely takes liberties with the kind of thrills that are contained in this movie.

The movie contains three horror comic-style stories: “The Telephone” is about a woman receiving threatening phone calls from a man who wants to kill her and can see everything she does. “The Wurdulak” is about a family dreading the return of their father, who went to the mountains to kill a vampire-like creature that craves the blood of the people it loved most in life. And “A Drop of Water” is about a nurse called in to help prepare the body of an old woman who died while conducting a séance.

Boris Karloff appears as the father in the second story, and he also delivers a charming segment as himself, as an introduction and an epilogue to the movie. In the first, he appears against a blue backdrop that’s a little reminiscent of Fantasia, and I won’t spoil the second except to say that it’s a repeat of what might be the most memorable image of the movie.

Those charming segments did a lot to nudge me over the precipice into liking this movie, since for the most part, it’s extraordinarily dull. The first segment has just enough tension to be engaging, the second feels like a fifteen minute story padded to twice that length, and the third is mostly memorable for an extremely creepy old woman whose face is locked in a rictus grimace.

It’s fun to see how much Mario Bava and his crew were experimenting with light and color. I’m pretty certain that the ruined cloister set that was used for Black Sunday also appears here, and it was honestly a lot more striking in black and white. Black Sabbath’s scenes work a lot better in tight, confined spaces, with colored light coming from out of a window, or a light unnaturally focused on Karloff’s menacing face as he’s riding on horseback. It’s never as dramatic as anything in Suspiria or even Vertigo, but you can really tell that a lot of attention was paid to getting the light and the color exactly right.

I suspect that Kino Lorber also put a lot of effort into making sure that the Italian version was the one released on physical media and streaming, because both Kanopy and Plex have the original title along with the Italian soundtrack and English subtitles. It’s one of those rare cases where I would’ve preferred a dubbed version, since it was simply distracting seeing Karloff speaking Italian. (The changes for the American release described in the Wikipedia entry sound pretty dreadful all around, so I guess I should be thankful).

It all feels pretty tame and old-school even by the standards of 1963, seemingly going more for suspense than for shocking horror. You can’t deny the artistry behind much of it, but it undeniably feels like a collection of the “filler” episodes of a lost anthology TV series.

V/H/S Halloween, or, One and a Half Reese’s In A Bucket Full of Bit-o-Honey

2026-10-30 02:38:35

Because I’m still most annoyed that V/H/S Halloween felt like a waste of time, I’ll respect yours and get right to the point: The last segment, “Home Haunt,” is very good, nails the right tone, and strikes the right balance between gory and fun. The second segment, “Ut Supra Sic Infra,” is clever and has a good punchline, but there’s not a whole lot to it. The rest are in the “don’t bother unless you’re bored” category, except for one called “Kidprint” that is pure garbage.

I’ve never seen any of the V/H/S found footage movies, but I’ve always been mildly curious about them. Horror anthologies are fantastic in concept, but in practice, they tend to have a very low hit rate. Maybe that’s a helpful reminder to all of us forced to live in the “AI era” that ideas aren’t worth anything without thoughtful execution of all the details bringing them about.

Even the “institutions” of horror anthology, like Creepshow and Tales from the Crypt, are hit-and-miss. And at least based on the marketing, V/H/S seemed to be aiming even lower, an anthology series for edgelords with a limited budget. But I’ve got the Shudder subscription anyway, and it’s Halloween week, so this seemed like the perfect place for me to start giving it a chance. Unfortunately, V/H/S Halloween didn’t do much to convince me otherwise.

A bit about the segments, in order from best to worst, using info borrowed from Wikipedia:

  • “Home Haunt” is by Micheline Pitt-Norman and RH Norman, and I liked it a lot. It’s very much going for the vibe of EC horror comics and traditional Halloween haunted houses, but in an environment where they don’t have to leave much to the imagination. Makeup and effects legend Rick Baker, who does his own famously sophisticated home haunts in the LA area, plays a neighbor in this, and it’s more than just a self-aware cameo; it feels like an endorsement and seal of approval. I think this one gets the tone exactly right, it doesn’t skimp on the gore or “they went there” moments, and it’s worth fast-forwarding to this one and watching it on its own.
  • “Ut Supra Sic Infra” by Paco Plaza and Alberto Marini is a Spanish-language entry set in Madrid, examining the aftermath of a bunch of 20-something partygoers sneaking into a famously haunted mansion one night. This one is pretty solid and well told, with a two-timelines-at-once format that makes the found footage concept work. (The idea of the police actually conducting an investigation like this is, of course, nonsense). It works mostly on vibes and anticipation, saving its most gruesome idea for a single scene, and ending on a clever punchline. The only downside of that restraint is that it feels like there’s not quite enough to it.
  • “Diet Phantasma” is the wraparound story, about a sinister company testing a new soda made from ghosts. The first gag is entertainingly over-the-top and goofy, but then it’s just the same joke repeated over and over and over again.
  • “Fun Size” is by Casper Kelly, who made the short Too Many Cooks and the feature Buddy, as well as a bunch of video projects for Adult Swim. In my opinion, this was the perfect example of something that probably seemed good in concept, but falls apart in the execution. It’s clearly trying to be surreal and darkly comedic, and everyone’s aware that they’re trying to play it broad and over-the-top, but nobody’s nailing it. It just feels like cheesy dialogue delivered in cheesy performances, all self-awareness with no substance.
  • “Coochie Coochie Coo” is pretty much what I’d imagined when I first heard of V/H/S. Found footage with annoying characters getting into an extreme situation with the vibe of a neighborhood haunted house given a Halloween Horror Nights or Knott’s Scary Farm-level budget. You can tell they spent money on a couple of the costumes/makeup effects, but it just gets a shrug because you spend the whole time thinking “these insufferable young women deserve everything that’s going to happen to them.”
  • “Kidprint” is trash. Just nothing redeemable about it at any level. And I feel the need to make sure that nobody gets the satisfaction of saying “ha-ha, get a load of this pearl-clutching Gen X-er who can’t handle horror that doesn’t pull any punches!” because it’s literally sophomoric. It overwhelmingly feels like a sophomore film student who’s convinced they’re bringing real world horror to a media landscape that demands all of the edges to be safely sanded away for public consumption, because they can’t handle the truth. But there’s absolutely no depth, it’s all amateurishly presented, and there’s an embarrassing lack of art to any of it. On top of all the clumsiness of it, the performances of the children are across the board better and more convincing than any of the adults. I’m really writing this post just to make a public declaration of what a complete failure this short was, at every conceivable level.

So my first exposure to the V/H/S definitely wasn’t a success. There’s one solid entry and another that’s pretty good, but the low points don’t feel as much like “this didn’t land for me, but you can’t win ’em all!” as “this series clearly has no quality control in place.”

It’s a shame, because I’m entirely on board with the concept, and anything that gives filmmakers the opportunity to get a wider audience, and established names the chance to make something in a freer and looser environment. I might give the series a couple more chances, because it has attracted some talent that I generally like. V/H/S/Beyond has a short by Kate Siegel and Mike Flanagan, and another by Justin Long. And V/H/S 99 has an entry from Vanessa Winter and Joseph Winter, who made one of my favorite horror movies, Deadstream, along with Melanie Stone, who was absolutely terrific in that movie.

I just won’t feel any obligation to sit through the parts that aren’t working, and instead feel free to skip to the parts I’m interested in.