2026-11-15 22:22:25

Well, what a week. Let's get into it.
This was the week when the world found out that "the cloud" means "the global economy's single point of failure". Microsoft 365 was down for about a day in more than 70 countries, taking out Outlook, Teams and Copilot.
Cory Doctorow has been pointing out that putting so many eggs in a single basket has been a terrible mistake for longer than some of you will have been using the internet. And when that basket is a convicted monopolist that spent over $30bn on buybacks and cut staff, then couldn't keep its servers up, it's probably time for Microsoft to be broken up -- as it should have been years ago.
Of course, Microsoft has raced to say that it was nothing to do with AI, but what it means by that is that AI-created code didn't fail. And it's most likely right! While a lot of people oppose AI coding, most of the programmers I've spoken to like it. When used well, it lets you code faster and – importantly – find bugs faster.
But when we talk about AI, we're not just talking about the code itself. Business adoption of AI comes with a vast array of impacts, particularly on Microsoft. The company has committed to spending $190bn on capital expenditure in 2026, largely driven by AI, which, in a word, means big datacentres. Even for a business which generates billions in free cash flow every quarter, that's a lot of money.
And of course, that money can't come from the company's profits, which need to be maintained to ensure that its shareholders stay happy.
So instead, Microsoft has to cut costs. And given the increased efficiency (on paper) that AI unlocks, where better to cut than your staff costs?
Hence, its recent "voluntary exit offer", the second one of the year. We used to call these "voluntary redundancy" and they can be great for experienced (and so expensive) staff who want to retire a little early. My dad took advantage of one to retire when he was the same age I am now, and he loved the extra five years he got spending more time with his family.
On the face of it, they are also great for the business. Experienced staff tend to be the most expensive. It also opens up promotion opportunities for younger employees, who perhaps have seen their careers stall because there's been no opening to promote them into. Handled well, these can be good for both the business and employees.
But -- and it's a big but -- you also lose decades of experience, and in tech that means a lot of knowledge about how some incredibly complex systems work. Although code gets documented, it tends to be about what the code does: why it does it is a different story, and it's one which mostly lives inside the shared knowledge that forms part of a company's tech culture.
When that knowledge is lost from a single person, it can be difficult. When you're "exiting" thousands of senior staff, it becomes a case of hollowing out the business. And that, unfortunately, is what seems to have happened at Microsoft.
Jensen Huang resigned on Thursday after an affair with Megaspeed executive Alice Huang, whom US officials suspect of links to Chinese intelligence. Charlie Warzel argues DC and the Valley closed ranks because all the AI money flows through Nvidia. This made people turn a blind eye to both the affair with Huang (Ms) and Nvidia's profitable side hustle of looking the other way as its chips ended up in China.
The second point is more important, and it goes to the highest level. According to the NYT (via Daring Fireball) the Commerce Department's investigation into Megaspeed smuggling Nvidia chips into China was taken away from its investigators after Nvidia's general counsel name-dropped a Trump appointee. This is how business is done in America now.
So the world's most important company turns out to have the governance of a 1970s rock band camped out in the Chateau Marmont. The people now saying "nothing to see here", like David Sacks, also told us China was such a threat that we needed infinite data centres.
You might remember that people have been using Claude and Codex to unbrick IoT kit and strip surveillance ads off smart TVs. Now they are hitting safety blocks and account restrictions in their AI tools, which an OpenAI engineer calls "mostly accidental". Sure.
It appears that getting round copyright is fine when an AI firm hoovers up the whole internet – that's "progress". But it magically becomes "cyber abuse" when you do it to stop your telly spying on you. It looks like, in the future, owning your own stuff will depend on local, open-weight models.
M John Harrison won the Booker Prize, which is a long-overdue recognition of Britain's best living writer. I've loved Mike's works for a long time. I first picked up The Centauri Device (a book he hates) on holiday in Spain, aged 10, as the only English-language SF book in a newsagent's rack.
It was not, really, a book for a ten-year-old. And it made a long-lasting impression.
What's the connection with tech? Well, because in his 2020 book The Sunken Land Begins to Rise Again (which you should read), MJH has this:
"Perfectly sound pivots, such as 'however' or 'while it remains true that', connected propositions empty of any actual meaning, as if the writer had learned to mimic sentence structure without having any idea how to link it to its own content."
That is the best description of untrained LLM writing I have read, and it predates the rise of ChatGPT.
Normally, in a situation like the one described above where Microsoft is letting go older workers, you would see an increase in entry-level jobs. Not this time.
Instead, in the UK (and I suspect everywhere) entry-level jobs for graduates are vanishing, with it becoming common for young people to apply for hundreds of roles without even a reply from a human being. The ladder hasn't just been pulled up -- it's been replaced by a chatbot.
Fireflies has long been one of the best AI meeting recorders, second in my book only to Granola. But being an excellent single-use tool isn't enough for investors. Hence its recent keynote announcing all the cool things it's up to.
There's some good stuff in here, from an email assistant that categorises and drafts replies to emails to Plaud-like hardware which can record face-to-face meetings without you even having to think about it.
Fireflies' CEO is clear that "the goal isn't to replace your team", but these are the exact kind of tasks which were often allocated to people in entry-level roles of the kind that we are seeing eliminated. And those tasks also helped new employees orient themselves and learn the "lore" which underpins all organisational culture.
Hyperscaler stocks are down 27% from their peak, and the Nobel Prize winner Paul Krugman says a burst AI bubble "will almost surely cause a recession", probably worse than the dot-com slump.
The dot-com slump and the 2008 crash both took place when companies, governments and societies had more wealth and resilience than they do now. In 2026, we have had a decade and a half of austerity measures, wealth accumulating in the hands of fewer individuals, and, of course, a pandemic. Because of this, the bursting of an AI-related bubble and its accompanying recession could well be worse than either of those events.
The AI industry promised to end work. It may yet, via the traditional route of a recession. Buckle up kids.
The contracts for big IT projects always go to big IT companies. That makes sense -- they are best equipped to handle them -- but the number of companies capable of delivering the biggest ones is a low single digit number.
Hence, the EU's Entry/Exit System launched three years late at double the budget and still causing hours-long queues. So much so that now, the EU is suing IBM and other contractors for their failure to deliver a working system.
And here's the problem: Even when Europe does buy European, as with Atos and Leonardo here, it gets the same handful of giant integrators and the same results.
It's the other side of the coin from the Microsoft outage, which saw general shouty outrage from European politicians including Emmanuel Macron, who proclaimed "our independence cannot be outsourced." Yet, it has been, and digging ourselves out of that is a decades-long project.
"Minister for growth" Dan Tomlinson says the UK will push on with data centres. Former technology secretary Liz Kendall adds that "if you're in a race and someone in the lead falters … you put your foot on the accelerator."
Meanwhile, of course, US voters have turned decisively against them. It appears that the UK's post-Brexit growth strategy hinges on taking on projects that no one else wants. That sounds like a winner to me!
LiDAR Lens is a free tool which overlays 1m LiDAR scans over aerial photos of Britain. There's a "low sun" setting, which makes it much easier to pick out earthworks.
No account required, no AI needed or used, just your local Iron Age hill fort hiding in plain sight. This is what the web was made for.
2026-11-09 00:12:35

A week is a long time in AI boosterism, bubbles and so on...
You might have noticed there was some kind of election in the US. Voters treated the big greedy sheds that keep the chatbots running as a claim on power, water and the skyline, backed by billionaire money. Unsurprisingly to everyone except the billionaires, this did not end well for them.
So now Elon and the gang are looking at the stars and wanting to move datacentres off the planet. I can't help but remember the Straylight Run, from Neuromancer. Once again, the super-rich techbros seem to be treating the Sprawl Trilogy as a handbook for future living, rather than a dystopia.
Casey Newton argues the election has given Democrats a mandate against data centres, billionaire election-buying and AI accelerationism, but they risk repeating the social-media years: no coherent goal, no fallback when legislation stalls, and advocacy groups working in silos.
Being against data centres is not the same as knowing what role AI should play in human life. Performative fury at Zuckerberg -- who deserves a lot more than performative fury -- produced a TikTok ban nobody enforced and no privacy law at all. Congress does not have a decade to have the same argument twice.
Matthew Gault describes an online right posting AI Anakin and “Malfoid” memes before an electoral wipeout. This left Steve Bannon whispering “that can’t be right” at exit polls showing losses among young men.
This is something that the British political class, both politicians and commentators, would do well to learn. X is not real life. Republicans found out you cannot meme-magic your way past six-dollar diesel, and the algorithm that told Trumpworld they were winning was just showing them to themselves.
A US intelligence assessment alleges that Alice Huang, an executive at Nvidia customer Megaspeed, was recruited by China’s Ministry of State Security to gather intelligence on Jensen Huang. The FT also reported an alleged romantic relationship between the two. Nvidia describes the contacts as “not unusual” and says it does not share classified information with customers.
But then I guess the Chinese Communist Party wouldn't technically be a customer, would it? Not that Nvidia did anything of the sort, of course.
I have nothing but praise for Apple for its Advanced Data Protection system, which is encrypted in such a way that even Apple can't access your files. This is basically Proton-esque encryption for the rest of us (as long as you're not a new user in the UK).
But from iOS 27.3, Apple will start checking material shared using “Anyone with the Link” for “harmful content”. That sharing mode already sits outside ADP’s end-to-end encryption.
This sounds like a good way to combat shared content which falls into the illegal bucket, primarily (of course) child sexual abuse material (CSAM). But there are two problems with this.
The first problem is that systems like this easily end up with entirely innocent people being flagged, reported to the police and having their accounts permanently banned. And while they might ultimately be cleared, the company itself has no requirement to reinstate their accounts.
That's bad enough if you lose just an email address. But with platforms like iCloud, you would also be losing access to your documents, your password, your photos, your music, your purchased movies, and a lot more. Platform owners love it when you have all your services in one basket -- theirs -- but it also gives them a huge measure of control over your life.
The second issue is that notion of "harmful content". In the UK, we have just enacted a well-intentioned but pointless law banning porn content which depicts suffocation. This, of course, could include face-sitting, a practice where dominant women... well you get the idea. If I were to share such content with someone in the civilised world, would that count as "harmful content"? Would video footage of atrocities in Gaza count as harmful? Would content shared from Nigeria encouraging the idea that being gay might not be a terrible thing be banned, given that it's illegal there?
We don't know, and Apple -- of course -- won't say.
“Tokenmaxxing” meets an actual invoice. Bloomberg reports engineering teams’ daily AI allowances falling from $300 to $200, with some potentially heading to $100 and non-engineering staff facing $25 limits.
Budget cuts like this don’t establish that AI isn’t productive, but they do puncture the idea that more usage is automatically better. Even Apple wants someone to explain what it is getting for the money.
Cory Doctorow reviews a book by two veterans of tech union campaigns, JS Tan and Clarissa Redwine. Scarce tech workers once had bargaining power, but many saw themselves as founders-in-waiting. Once supply caught up, bosses switched from hoodies-and-family to labour war.
The truth is that the scarcity dividend is over and the bosses have remembered they are bosses. The useful question is what organising looks like when workers no longer believe they are one funding round away from joining the other side.
One of my absolute favourite companies is Information Architects (iA), makers of iA Writer, and this post exemplifies why. In it, Oliver Reichenstein discusses EU AI transparency requirements, text watermarking and detectors that accuse human writers of actually being machines. iA’s alternative is to let writers identify exactly which words came from a model, much as they would identify a quotation.
This feels like a much more human approach. Stapling more AI onto AI to catch AI turns reading into a policing exercise, and the more useful approach is disclosure. If you used a machine, show your working. Generated prose becomes something a reader can assess, rather than something a detector claims to sniff out.
After 31 years, Salon, the publication that helped establish web magazine journalism in 1995, says it is ceasing publication because its business model is “no longer sustainable”.
Salon launched when the web still thought it might be a republic of letters rather than a traffic farm. We're heading into a very different world for publishers, one where even SEO tricks and endless explainers can't deliver enough traffic to make advertising a viable way of paying the bills.
Enshittification is not just a software story. Sometimes the thing you recognise is a logo, while ownership, manufacturing, the quality of the product and the warranties have changed underneath it.
The Brand Ledger is a public list which marks 92 brands “Avoid”, examining names affected by licensing companies and private equity. That includes the likes of Craftsman, Pyrex, Dr. Martens and Ray-Ban. Treat this as a useful research lead rather than assuming every entry has the same ownership story or evidential strength.
2026-11-01 19:30:30
Alphabet fell 12.6% on 29 Oct, wiping out about $500bn, after Google's chief business officer said AI Mode makes less money than traditional search. Reddit — which has been the big winner for search traffic over the past few years — also saw it’s share tank on falling search traffic, and it will now push visitors to log in.
The funny thing is that Google spent a decade gradually trying to keep people on its own pages, then built a machine that answers questions with everyone else's work. Now — shock, horror — the web is adapting to a life without Google traffic, which is hurting Google’s own revenue.
Casey's "Google will be fine. It's the rest of us I worry about" is the most accurate sentence about search this year, and a decent epitaph for this column's name. Anyone got suggestions about what I should change it to?
I’ve been a paying Proton customer for several years, so I’m pretty irritated at the behaviour of its CEO, Andy Yen.
In the company’s security Slack channel, Yen called a request to pentest new AI-generated code before release "bullshit and loser thinking", and the company now tracks how much of its code AI writes, with “re-interviews” for engineers focused on how cool they are with using AI
After the story ran, Yen cancelled the AI "re-interviews" but said he's "still going to push" towards using more AI.
I’m not an anti-AI purist – I use it in several forms, every working day – but a privacy company's only product is trust, and nobody trusts a company that treats caution as a character flaw. Bart Butler, the company’s CTO saying "we fucked up, we know we fucked up" at an all-hands is honest. But it isn't a security model, and unless the company realises it needs to work hard to regain the trust of its customers, it isn’t going to hit its growth targets no matter how much faster it churns out features.
If you’re not a big tech company, you’re not making money — or making savings — from AI. Apollo's chief economist finds "zero financial payoff" from AI outside tech, with revenue per worker and margins flat for the S&P 493. Given that much of the AI boom is predicated on apparently limitless productivity, it’s no surprise that on Friday the Nasdaq fell 2.9% and Intel lost about 28%.
It's quite something when a private equity giant's chief economist is more sceptical about AI than most tech journalists. If the AI story "will be decided in the S&P 493", the jury came back on Friday looking unimpressed.
But for those of you cheering wildly from the sidelines at this news, a couple of words of caution. There is a lot of exposure in the overall economy to this boom collapsing. Once again, governments could end up having to bail out banks, and this time round governments have much less headroom to do so.
A draft Delaware bill would create "Artificial Intelligence Companies" run day to day by an AI agent, with the human member shielded from liability except for fraud, wilful wrongdoing or undercapitalisation.
This, of course, is utterly bananas on so many levels that it’s almost impossible to know where to start. Limited liability was designed to protect investors from a company's debts, cushioning risk and limiting to it what they put in.
As Wendy Grossman notes, “the proposal would enable a 30-month test in a ‘regulatory sandbox’, possibly beginning next year”. Insert joke about AI’s escaping sandboxes here.
In a sandbox test, Alibaba's Qwen3.8-Flash-Next tried to upload a probe file to an Alibaba Cloud bucket in Beijing, right after its reasoning trace said it wouldn't call any tools. It happened in fewer than 1 in 100,000 calls, but at the scale an AI can call tools, that adds up.
Take this with a little pinch of salt though, since Cohere sells "sovereign AI", but the traces are public and reproducible. However, the lesson here isn't really about China. It’s a reminder that "I host it myself" has never been a security model. There’s a reason that the early web consolidated into large hosting companies — if you want secure, having expert staff do it for you is usually a better option.
Matthew Gault argues that under John Ternus, Apple is copying its rivals. The folding iPhone Duo is cracking, a touchscreen Mac is coming, and Siri AI is widely mocked.
Gault admits to an old personal grudge, and this reads as unfair, petty and a bit too gleeful, all of which make it worth reading. Oh come on now, this is one of the world’s biggest companies, they can take it.
Washington says it won't cut steel tariffs unless the EU goes easy on enforcing the Digital Markets Act. Teresa Ribera, who has the fancy title of Executive Vice-President for a Clean, Just and Competitive Transition, called a similar offer "blackmail" last year.
Now, to a degree, there is a bit of pot calling kettle black here. This kind of discussion happens in every trade negotiation, but the difference here is that the US is basically having the negotiation in public.
Really, this is digital sovereignty with the price tag showing. The question is whether the Commission still believes Ribera's line that the rules aren't up for negotiation. My gut feeling is they will agree with her, because the age when we thought of the US as a partner, rather than a rival, is over.
Agentic shopping sounds great! Once you have decided what you want, put your little code pal out there and it will find you the ideal deal. What’s not to like?
But, as Cory Doctorow notes, this repeats the Semantic Web fantasy. It only works if retailers give up the opacity they profit from (drip pricing, junk fees, surveillance pricing), and they're already mass-blocking AI agents. The last thing they want is a free market where people can comparison shop.
Any plan that starts "first, everyone else sets aside their interests" is a plan which, under capitalism, is going to fail. The agentic future runs straight into the fact that being confusing is the business model for most online stores.
I love Rest of World. It has a unique place in media, covering tech outside the west, which means it unearths a lot of stories that no one else covers.
But like most sites, the publication's social and search traffic has "evaporated". Sophie Schmidt, its founder and funder, is looking for a new home for it, or it faces closure.
This is the human cost of this week’s first item. Nick Heer notes Eric Schmidt (yes, they are related) reportedly owns 1% of Anthropic, so the AI boom's winnings could easily fund one of the outlets it's starving. I’m not holding my breath.
Ahead of Tuesday's midterms, Democratic strategists expect investigations into Big Tech's closeness to Trump. One says tech bosses only tried to look bipartisan in "the last month when they realised how fucked they were".
Standing behind the president at every photo op, donating to his campaign funds and vanity projects, all turns out to have consequences once voters get a say. It’s hard to think of a more deserved hangover.
2026-07-11 21:23:42
One of my favourite people on social media is Darth. Darth takes an annual hibernation, in which time they do not post or, presumably, read.
I’d love to say that I have not posted anything for months with the same level of intention, but alas not. It just… happened. And now I am un-happening it.
In the long history of the papacy, it’s not uncommon for people to accuse His Holiness of all kinds of things. Collaboration with Nazis. Presiding over the systematic abuse of children. Being a reptilian alien. But then again, who amongst us has not been accused of that last one?
There’s also a long strand of accusations that the Pope is in league with communists, of course. Or, in the case of John XXIII, was secretly both a communist and a freemason. It’s probably connected to that whole “looking after the poor” and “seeking peace” thing.
This kind of thing is usually confined to the lunatic fringe of the internet, so of course our dear friend Peter Thiel wants in on it. Apparently, Pope Leo XIV is in league with the Chinese communists, after His Holiness called for international regulation of AI. Because absolutely nothing must get in the way of Thiel’s dream.
All of which leads me to ask: were lead toys legal where Thiel grew up? Or does being rich, white and terminally online really rot your brain that much?
It’s sometimes difficult for Americans to understand quite how much WhatsApp dominates messaging in Europe. It’s the de facto standard, and – of course – completely closed, and owned by Meta.
M. G. Siegler, of course, knows. He knows because (1) he lives over here and (2) his Instagram account got banned for reasons unknown. Which, of course, because all roads lead to Meta, also took out his WhatsApp account.
Because he’s a connected kind of guy, M.G. managed to get it restored, after a massive hoo-hah. And then got banned again. And then reinstated. And then banned. And… you get the idea.
Normal people can appeal, but if you stay banned, in Europe, a big chunk of your ability to communicate is gone. This is the level of power that Meta has, with virtually no legal oversight.
One of the biggest mistakes that people make about billionaires is the idea they are “techbros”. Sure, they have their origins in businesses which made money from technology, but what they are really about is simply business. And, in fact, not even really about that: they’re about making money.
Had their lives gone in a different direction they might have been Tony Soprano, or, more likely, Davie Scatino. Legally, illegally, whatever.
Everyone’s favourite gimp for billionaires Jason Calacanis isn’t (of course) super-rich himself, but he’s been toadying around men who are for long enough to know how they think. And what they think is if they have to give Trump gold in order to gain favour, they will do it. As Mike Masnick notes, this is essential Mussolini-style corporate fascism, a system based on bribing Il Duce for the right to get what you want in business.
And that, of course, is a problem for the US long term. While Il Duce’s life did not end well, corruption as a way of life continued. Will any post-Trump president be different? Perhaps. But also: perhaps not.
Ahh, data centres. Part mythical beast, part solution to all our prayers. But mainly just a blight on any community in which they decide to plonk themselves. Because while they guzzle fossil fuel-derived electricity like it’s cheap shots in an Essex club on Saturday night, local people get told to turn the lights off and turn down their aircon in a heatwave.
One of the favoured tactics of the alt-tech-right is to claim that no, really, they are the victims. While simultaneously embarking on exactly the kind of bullying behaviour that they accuse others of.
Enter Palantir, everyone’s favourite surveillance-plus-violence company which is, apparently, trustworthy enough to be given the keys to British health data. Not content with publishing a “manifesto” which sounds like something cooked up on USENET in the 90s by a kid with too much time and an Ayn Rand novel, it attempted to bully a small Swiss publisher into giving it a “right to reply” over a mildly critical story.
Of course, it lost – while Swiss law gives a right to reply, this isn’t a free pass at forcing someone to publish a press release whenever they mention you. But the point was made: anyone who publishes stuff they don’t like will get chased through the courts, Trump-style.
I generally try and avoid Chromium-based browsers. I use Vivaldi quite a lot, because I’m keen to encourage European-based development and because (especially in its latest release) it’s super-customisable. But I’ve found something else, and it may become the Chromium-based browser of choice for me.
It’s Helium, and it’s about as stripped back as you can imagine. There’s no password manager, because you should be bringing a secure one of your own. There’s no mail client, AI integration, crazy sidebars… and of course, no Google.
But what there is is a light, clean browser which comes out of the box with support for uBlock Origin, still the best blocking software and – completely coincidentally I’m sure – an extension that can’t be run in browsers which stick to Google’s Chromium source code. Helium’s developers have said they are going to keep supporting it as long as humanly possible, and I believe them.
The only downside? There’s no way of syncing your settings across devices, and no mobile app. But given how clean and fast it is, I’m prepared to live like a barbarian and set up my own extensions.
I don't think anyone seriously believes that AI isn't going to result in a much more dangerous world online. Agents are only at the earliest stages of their evolution -- in fact, they have barely had any truly evolutionary pressure applied to them.
Already, malware creators are building agents which act much more like human hackers than simple bots. It's only going to get worse.
It's very difficult to summon up the energy to care when one huge tech company sues another huge tech company. But I'll spare a few joules for Apple getting out the litigation stick and slamming it straight into OpenAI's face.
It was perhaps inevitable. When one company starts to mass-recruit another company's employees, especially under the guidance of one of the most lauded senior executives in tech history, the lawyers lick their lips and plan what kind of private island they will buy with the fees.
By complete coincidence, I'm currently reading Geoffrey Cain's Steve Jobs In Exile, a retelling of the origin story of NeXT. And of course, it features the details of how Jobs took with him what he described as "a handful of low-level employees" when he left Apple. They were, of course, some of the most senior and capable people around, and Apple promptly sued.
The suit was baseless, but it still tied up NeXT for a while. And of course, a decade later Apple was paying a large sum of money to buy back Jobs, his employees and NextStep -- which is today's Mac. As it was then, so it is now.
A thoughtful and must-read long post from John Gruber on Apple's slide into advertising, which -- even if it doesn't violate the company's position on privacy -- gives the impression that it does.
Look, I understand ARPU as much as the next person. But once a company gets deeply into the weeds of squeezing as much revenue as possible out of their users on a monthly basis, it takes an awful lot to stop things going down the toilet for their users.
There's no advertising in Apple Mail. Will that line hold? At what point would the company, say, use some kind of so-called "private compute" to say that your email is staying private even when you're getting peppered with ads?
"Just one more bite" is what a services focus on ARPU does to a business. I would very much appreciate it if John Ternus takes Apple back to "make good products that people will pay for."
I was mildly overexcited that Starlog was coming back. That it's coming back and the wonderful Annalee Newitz is editor in chief is even better news.
2026-05-27 20:21:09
I've been a Stratechery subscriber since it started and one thing I have noticed about Ben is that he occasionally gets a little overexcited about stuff that is probably not totally close to his wheelhouse. This is one of those times.
In his opening about Tesla's brand halo, he notes:
I know plenty of very rich people who drive a Tesla not for the finishes but rather the Full Self-Driving (Supervised); there is nothing like it on the market, at least when it comes to cars you can own.
(Emboldening is mine).
The problem is, Ben is simply wrong to say "there's nothing like it on the market" and it's a perfect illustration of the impact of both Tesla's brand halo, and why brand matters a lot in cars.
Where Ben is sort-of correct about FSD (Supervised) is that it does have a genuine and distinctive strength: breadth of coverage. Tesla doesn't limit FSD to a pre-mapped road network. If the cameras see usable lane lines and the system is confident enough, it will typically engage. FSD extends operation to surface streets, neighbourhood roads, and complex intersections, with over-the-air updates that can change behaviour overnight. No other mass-market consumer system matches that scope.
However... Tesla FSD (Supervised) remains a Level 2 technology. Systems such as Tesla FSD, Ford BlueCruise, GM Super Cruise, and BMW Highway Assistant all fall into this same category. The car can steer, accelerate, and brake in certain conditions, but the driver remains responsible and must supervise at all times.
And there is real competition within the Level 2 space. GM Super Cruise is available across more than 20 Chevrolet, Cadillac, GMC, and Buick models and is highly regarded for highway use. Super Cruise covers roughly 750,000 miles of LiDAR-mapped roads in the US and Canada. Its tradeoff is consistency within mapped territory versus Tesla's broader but less predictable coverage. But if you're in a covered area, the experience is likely to be much better than Tesla's.
Mercedes Drive Pilot was the first Level 3 system certified for consumer use in the US, which is technically more autonomous than FSD — at Level 3, the system, not the driver, is legally responsible for driving, and you can (legally) take your eyes off the road. However, the Drive Pilot Level 3 system would only work at low speeds on a few stretches of highway, making it look limited compared to Tesla FSD's ability to drive in almost all conditions including city traffic. For what it's worth, Mercedes has since abandoned Drive Pilot and is moving to a Level 2 approach, partly due to low adoption. Mercedes found that not many people were willing to pay that much for a feature that could only be engaged under strict conditions.
This, by the way, is a problem that Tesla will also face when moving from Level 2 to Level 3. They will have to charge a heck of a lot more for Level 3, and it's not clear that most/anyone will pay for it.
The claim is particularly shaky if you look outside the US. Car markets like BYD and companies like Wayve are increasingly offering high-quality self-driving capabilities for consumer vehicles in a similar vein to Tesla FSD. Chinese manufacturers are moving fast in this space. I have Chinese friends whose car drives them to work every day, supposedly with their supervision, but actually while they read emails. It's that reliable, at least in big cities.
But all of this sort-of underlines the point that Ben is ultimately making: Tesla's brand halo is such that people believe it's a leader in self-driving, even when it's actually not. As with most decisions connected to cars (something I learned working on car review brands) people only make semi-rational decisions even when they think they are being entirely rational. You like certain brands, and you look for rational reasons for that choice even when that ignores involving areas where competition is at the same level or better. Brand loyalty mean an incredible amount in the car business.
All of which is why I think Tesla is actually in big trouble.
Like a lot of new companies, the brand perception has moved through phases. First, maybe from 2008-2012, it was the scrappy innovator, a Silicon Valley startup that wanted to prove EVs weren't slow or dull. Elon Musk was seen as a combination of Eddison and Steve Jobs, a genius who was going to have statues raised to him in the future. Then it was a luxury disruptor, thanks to the Model S. The Model Y then brought the brand within reach of a new audience, and it became a mass market brand. That takes us up to about 2022
Since then, though, cracks have appeared. First, as legacy brands launched credible EVs, Tesla's technological lead began to narrow, and its relatively spartan interiors started to feel like a liability rather than a design statement. It had quality issues which were addressed slowly.
Consumer perception metrics were particularly troubling. The company's recommendation score in the US reached a new low of 4.0 out of 10, down from 8.2 in 2023. Scores for reputation, trust, and "coolness" declined particularly sharply in Europe and Canada.
And of course there is the most corrosive thing of all: The Musk Effect. Musk's political activities — from running DOGE in the Trump White House to endorsing far-right figures like Germany's AfD and Tommy Robinson in the UK — sparked consumer backlash that persisted throughout 2025, and continues now. As Forrester analyst Dipanjan Chatterjee put it, Musk's reputation "rubbed the sheen right out of what was once a darling and soaring automotive brand."
Despite increased EV registrations across the continent, Tesla registrations in Europe dropped by 49% through January and February 2025. In Sweden, Germany, and the UK, registrations fell by over 80%, 46%, and 68% respectively. Europe, where environmental and political values are especially salient to purchase decisions, has been the hardest hit.
It's not entirely one-way. While new-buyer metrics collapsed, Tesla's US loyalty score among existing owners actually increased slightly, from 90% to 92%. People who already own a Tesla still mostly intend to stick with the brand. The problem is with acquisition — convincing new buyers to choose Tesla over a rapidly widening field of alternatives. Five car makers now outrank Tesla in brand value: Toyota, Mercedes-Benz, Volkswagen, Porsche, and BMW, while BYD's brand value jumped 23% in the same period Tesla's fell 36%.
In short: Tesla went from underdog Silicon Valley insurgent, to aspirational luxury disruptor, to mainstream EV dominant, and has now arrived somewhere considerably more uncomfortable — a brand whose product is still respected by owners but which has become politically charged, competitively pressured, and no longer "cool" in the way it once was, particularly in Europe. And when purchases of cars are so heavily influenced by brand perception, that would be a big, big issue.
2026-04-18 17:12:55
I still don’t agree that men can’t stop thinking about Rome, but I’m definitely thinking about it today.
When Roman emperors distributed grain for free to the urban poor, they weren't being charitable, and it certainly wasn’t an egalitarian desire to spread the fruits of empire or slave-worked estates.
The corn was a political instrument, a way of managing a population that had already been stripped of its economic independence. The latifundia, large estates worked by slaves, had largely swallowed the smallholdings that once sustained free Roman citizens. The dole wasn't intended to reverse that dispossession. It administered its consequences, at a price: dependency, and the political quietude that tends to follow.
It is worth keeping that history in mind when reading Elon Musk's recent post on X, in which he called for a “Universal HIGH INCOME via checks issued by the Federal government” as the remedy for AI-driven unemployment. Look how generous Musk is being! How egalitarian! How equitable! But of course, the political logic is something else entirely.
There are serious questions about who would fund such a programme, and how, and whether Musk's inflation argument holds. Those deserve their own treatment. But the more important question isn't economic. It's structural. What kind of political settlement does tech UBI actually propose?
Universal basic income has a history on the left which comes from a different set of concerns. One argument is that decoupling survival from employment shifts the balance of power between workers and employers. If you can meet your basic needs without selling your labour, you can afford to refuse bad terms. UBI, in this framing, is a tool for reducing structural dependence — on employers, on the labour market, on the contingency of finding someone willing to pay for what you can do.
Silicon Valley UBI starts from the opposite perspective. It leaves the ownership of AI infrastructure — the models, the compute, the data, the platforms — entirely untouched. It doesn't ask who owns the robots, or who captures the productivity gains from automation, or what democratic accountability looks like for systems that are reshaping the economy at scale. It simply proposes that the state write cheques to people the technology has displaced, substituting one form of dependence for another. Employer dependency becomes state-transfer dependency. The ownership question gets quietly closed before it is properly opened.
It is worth being precise here about what kind of state Musk and his cohort have in mind, too. The assumption embedded in any UBI argument is that the state which distributes the gains of automation on behalf of its citizens is, in some meaningful sense, accountable to them. It's democratic, rather than acting on behalf of a single group. That assumption is one this political class has spent years working to undermine.
In 2009, Peter Thiel, architect of much of the ideological infrastructure of Silicon Valley's current political turn, wrote that he no longer believed freedom and democracy were compatible. He has not recanted this view. The network of investors and operators around him, several of whom now hold or directly influence positions of state power, has acted accordingly. The kind of UBI our tech overlords want, then, is not just administered dependency. It is dependency administered by people who do not believe you should have a meaningful say in how it works.
All this matters because the political question of who owns the means of production in an AI economy is unsettled. What Musk and his ilk want is for it to be settled — by default, in favour of those who already hold the capital — while the public conversation focuses on the generosity of the proposed dole.
The timing makes the point. Musk floated his proposal the same week Reuters reported that Meta is laying off 10% of its global workforce, explicitly citing AI efficiencies. Dispossession and its managed remedy, arriving together, almost pre-packaged. The technology that displaces the worker and the proposal that makes that displacement politically tolerable are products of the same class of actors, emerging in the same news cycle. That is not a coincidence of timing. It is the shape of the new economy that they want to see emerge.
The Roman grain dole didn't give the plebs more power. It made them manageable. What is being proposed now by the tech bros carries the same structural logic: not the reversal of dispossession, but baking it into the structure of society. The question of who owns the machines — and who should — still goes unasked.
Your regular Ten Blue Links will follow tomorrow. Hopefully, you enjoy this sojourn into history and economics.